Why is there no garbage collection in C++?

514    Asked by JannetteUhrig in Java , Asked on Oct 6, 2022

Well, I know that there are things like malloc/free for C, and new/using-a-destructor for memory management in C++, but I was wondering why there aren't "new updates" to these languages that allow the user to have the option to manually manage memory, or for the system to do it automatically (garbage collection)?

Answered by Jasmine Forsyth

Garbage collection in C++ requires data structures for tracking allocations and/or reference counting. These create overhead in memory, performance, and the complexity of the language. C++ is designed to be "close to the metal", in other words, it takes the higher performance side of the tradeoff vs convenience features. Other languages make that tradeoff differently. This is one of the considerations in choosing a language, which emphasis you prefer.


That said, there are a lot of schemes for reference counting in C++ that are fairly lightweight and performant, but they are in libraries, both commercial and open source, rather than part of the language itself. Reference counting to manage object lifetime is not the same as garbage collection, but it addresses many of the same kinds of issues, and is a better fit with C++'s basic approach.



Your Answer

Interviews

Parent Categories